02 September 2020

Executing Estate Planning Instruments In The Era Of Covid-19.

I'm a solo practitioner whose law practice is focused on crafting estate planning documents for clients in Minnesota: primarily Basic Wills, Powers of Attorney, and Advance Health Care Directives. The scope of my practice is limited to those services at this time and it does not include trusts or probate administration.

Until about six months ago I had the agility to move about freely, meeting clients on-the-fly to discuss their legal needs in locations that were convenient for them. I would draft their documents, and come time to sign them, I would gather the client and witnesses together at my office, or sometimes in the client's home. Whatever it took to accommodate their busy lifestyles.

Then the novel coronavirus hit in March and Minnesota wisely turned back the dial. At first, only essential services were allowed to operate. Even if I could keep operating, potential clients simply were not interested in meeting with estate planning attorneys and they had other things to think about. My law practice was quiet for several months.

Now that things have been opening up somewhat, I am being approached by people interested in obtaining Wills and other estate planning instruments. I started formulating in my mind how I would do this in a safe and efficient manner. Given the controversy over the reopening of businesses and schools, I am keenly aware of the well-founded fears many people have at this time. I certainly want to exercise an abundance of caution and would never wish to add risk to the equation.

Fortunately, working with clients on estate planning documents can be done mostly remotely. When someone makes initial contact I can communicate by email, phone, or text to gather basic information and answer preliminary questions. I can send out an electronically-fillable questionnaire that the prospective client can complete and email back. A short no-cost initial consultation by phone can help fill in the blanks for both attorney and prospective client. If the client chooses to engage my services, I then move forward with drafting their documents.

The pinch point arises when it's time to sign (execute) the documents. The execution requires at least four people to meet in one place. The client signs in the physical presence of two witnesses, then the witnesses sign. I am a Notary Public, so I sign and notarize the self-proving affidavit which is incorporated into the Will.

The testator, witnesses and I must meet in-person, with a clear line-of-sight of one another throughout the process. Although Notary functions can be performed remotely, Minnesota law does not allow wills to be witnessed remotely. 

Note that in April, Minnesota enacted the "Harmless Error Rule," allowing non-executed Wills to be recognized by the courts--so long as there is clear and convincing evidence showing that the testator had intended for the Will to be controlling. That means if you die before your Will has been properly executed, the document must be entered into formal probate. A judge then makes the determination--by a clear and convincing evidentiary standard--as to whether the document reflects your intent. This harmless error rule is temporary, and expires Feb. 15, 2021.

Therefore, as a practical matter, the formality of an in-person meeting of some sort is still a necessity to properly execute the documents. How to do this and maintain social distancing?

I initially thought that gathering everyone in a room in my office would be best. No more traveling to execute documents at clients' homes. I could easily keep everyone more than six feet apart, we'd all wear masks, and the physical presence requirement of Will execution would be fulfilled. But it just didn't sit right with me. There had to be a better way.

After some more thought, I decided that I was not comfortable even using that in-office protocol. Though the execution process takes only about 15-20 minutes, I simply did not want to risk the safety of my clients, myself, and others around us by having four or five people together in a small room indoors, coming in and out of doorways and such. 

I knew I had to further reduce the risk, and physically meeting with others in a room would not do.

One of my high school friends practices estate planning law at a small firm in another state that requires similar formalities. I asked him for advice. He said his firm does a sort of "curbside document execution" service. The client drives into the firm's parking lot and remains in their car. The attorney and staff come out to the car, documents in hand. Everyone performs their role in the execution while outdoors. Signing, witness signatures, notarization. Brilliant!

I have adapted a version of that curbside method, instructing the client to arrive at the driveway of my office at the appointed time. I, the witnesses, and the client will be able to sign off everything while the client is safely ensconced in their car and the rest of us are safely standing outside. Everyone with masks on. After the execution is complete, I can electronically scan the completed documents for my records, and hand the originals to the client to take home (I don't store original documents for clients).

Sadly, this adaptation has changed the face of my practice in more ways that just logistical. I miss the face-to-face meetings with clients in a quiet coffee shop. I miss building a rapport with the clients, the few minutes of small talk before we delve into business. I miss clients showing me pictures of their kids or talking about a recent vacation. But more than anything, I miss being there in-person to discuss the client's needs. But this is a small price to pay and is what needs to be done to protect people.

In the era of Covid-19, it's all-business and the rule of the day is to keep things brief and to the point. Get in, get out. Easy and safe.
 
 * * *
 
A good estate planning attorney can help you get started with a plan that is tailored to your wishes and goals, and help protect your assets for your loved ones.
 

31 August 2020

13 Estate Planning Myths Debunked.

In the world of estate planning, urban legends abound. Here are a few:

✦ Only high net worth estates need a plan. If you want to ensure that your family members receive your property according to your wishes, you need an estate plan. This should include a Will. Even if your estate size is modest, your loved ones will some day benefit from receiving your assets. In fact, if you have a spouse or children, a good estate plan is critical for protecting their future financial needs.

✦ I don't need a Will until I'm older. This is similar to the above-mentioned myth. You may be young and just starting your career. You might rent and not have many possessions or own real property at this time. But your assets will grow, as will your income and family. You might be putting money into accounts to plan for the future. If you have young children, you should think about protecting them financially in the event something happens. Plus, you don't want your loved ones trying to sort out your assets later.

✦ All I need is a simple Will for my estate planning. First, there is no "simple" Will. Your Will should be sophisticated enough to reasonably protect your assets while being responsive to your particular needs. While there is no "airtight" Will that is immune to contest, a well-crafted Will should be sufficiently robust to protect your assets and provide peace of mind. And yes, you should have one if you don't already.

However, a Will is only one tool to have in your estate planning toolbox. There are two others to consider, instruments that can help protect your interests while you are still alive.

First, a Durable Power of Attorney, to appoint someone you trust to manage your financial affairs in the event you are unable to do so yourself. And second, a Health Care Directive, to allow you to specify the kinds of medical treatment you wish to receive in the event of serious illness or incapacity. The Health Care Directive can be used to appoint one or more health care agents, who will be able to make those treatment decisions on your behalf.

✦ Once I have a Will, I'm set for life. A well-designed Will can anticipate some minor changes, but more significant life events warrant revisiting the Will. Getting married/divorced, having new children, grandchildren, buying or selling real property, are some of the life events that should trigger having your existing Will reexamined. You may only need to get a codicil (amendment) to the existing Will, or you may need to have an entirely new Will drafted. See a qualified estate planning attorney to find out the best course of action to keep your estate plan up to date.

✦ To disinherit someone, you must leave a dollar to them in your Will. This one is silly, but it stubbornly persists.  

In most cases you already have the legal right to disinherit someone (i.e., a child or grandchild). Leaving a dollar is unnecessary.

But if you don't have the legal right to disinherit someone (i.e., your spouse), leaving a dollar is completely irrelevant to the fact that your spouse has property rights and still receives a share of your estate. You cannot disinherit a spouse by means of a Will, no matter what language you put in it.

And if you're thinking you want to disinherit your spouse, you're probably in more need of a family law attorney.

✦ I can just write my own Will and sign it myself. This is called a holographic Will, and these handwritten Wills are recognized as valid in several states. However, Minnesota is not one of those states, and holographic Wills in this state will be disregarded by the probate courts. In addition, a holographic Will made in another state that does recognize them will still not be recognized in Minnesota. Your estate will be treated as intestate (as if the Will never existed) and your property will be divided per the laws of intestate succession.

There are some formalities required to properly execute a Will. Seeking the assistance of an estate planning attorney will help to ensure that your Will is well-crafted to meet your needs.

✦ An estate plan won't protect my digital assets. This is no longer true, as the Revised Uniform Fiduciary Access to Digital Assets Act (RUFADAA) has been adopted into law by almost every state, including Minnesota in 2016. Digital assets, such as documents, images, audio, video, that are stored online or on computer equipment, can be accessed and managed by the agents you have named in your Will or Power of Attorney.

✦ I don't need a Will if I'm using a Transfer on Death Deed. You should seriously consider having a valid Will, even if you have a TODD and the remainder of your estate is too small to require probate. Dying without a Will (intestacy), creates some uncertainties and your remaining assets may not end up being distributed the way you envisioned. A well-crafted Will can allow you to direct the distribution of your estate the way you want it. If you wish to give assets in unequal shares to family members, disinherit someone, give property to a non-family member, or donate to a charity, the laws of intestate succession have no provisions to allow for that. Those wishes will go unheeded by the court.

A Will also enables you to nominate the personal representative of your choice. With an intestate estate, the probate court appoints a PR without any input from you.

✦ Probate is something to be avoided at all costs. This is something touted all over the internet, and you might see financial "gurus" on TV advocating this idea. However, the probate process is more streamlined that you may think, and there are some advantages to it.

Probate can help ensure that the wishes stated in your Will are followed through. It limits the time creditors can make claims, allows a means for fair analysis of estate value, recognizes guardians for minor children, and duly appoints the personal representative. The court often requires an accounting of the estate assets, removing doubt from the minds of your heirs.

Of course, there are some disadvantages to probate: Fees, delays in transfer of assets, and public disclosure of the probate process are a few things to consider.

✦ Taxes on my estate will be onerous. Estate taxes are payed out of the estate before assets are distributed to beneficiaries. Inheritance taxes are payed by the beneficiaries on assets they receive from an estate. There is no federal or Minnesota inheritance tax. Only a few other states collect inheritance taxes. However, both the IRS and Minnesota collect estate taxes.

Federal estate taxes top out at 40%, but there is an exemption of $11.58 million per person. Minnesota's estate tax rate caps at 16%, and it allows a $3 million exemption per person. The vast majority of estates are valued below those exemptions, and as such would not be subject to estate taxes.

If your estate is valued above an exemption, it would be wise to sit down with a financial planner or tax advisor to determine what options are available.

✦ All of my property can be disposed in my Will. Your Will only disposes "probate" property that is in your name alone, and does not have named beneficiaries. Real property held in joint tenancy with right of survivorship (e.g. by two spouses) will transfer to the surviving joint tenant without probate when one of the tenants dies.

Many assets are transferred directly to named beneficiaries upon your death and are not transferred by a Will. These include life insurance policies, investment accounts, retirement accounts, and bank assets with payable on death (POD) designations. Real property can be transferred similarly, by means of a transfer on death deed (TODD).

✦ I need a new Will whenever my assets change. While it is wise to revisit your estate plan any time you have made major changes, such as buying/selling real property, most of your personal assets (and who you want to give them to) can be incorporated into your Will by means of a separate list. There's no need to amend or replace your Will whenever you buy a new car or some jewelry.

Minnesota law allows you to make an informal list of tangible personal property items, and that list is reference in a paragraph in your Will. As you acquire and get rid of personal items, you are free to amend that list as often as you like, without the need to change the Will. The list may be as simple as a sheet or two of notebook paper, but it must be written, signed and dated by you. The list cannot include money, coin collections or property used in your trade or business. 

✦ Getting an estate plan is too complicated. While there is no such thing as a "simple" Will, and the thought of drafting a Will, Power of Attorney and Health Care Directive may be intimidating, a qualified estate planning attorney can help you sort through the process. Some attorneys offer free or low-cost initial consultations to answer your preliminary questions and help you get started.

30 August 2020

Clickbait "Legal Articles" Written by Unqualified Authors: Empty Calories.

Consumers often search online for some basic information before consulting an attorney. It's part of being a prudent consumer--looking for useful information, trying to determine what questions need to be addressed, and hopefully finding something that will point their feet in the right direction, to the right people. 

Others search the internet for information in lieu of consulting an attorney. This is where things get dicey.

As is the case with any subject matter online, there's a lot of information that is incomplete at best, and erroneous and potentially harmful at worst. Relying on bad legal information can cost you dearly later on.

The internet is rife with junk articles, peppered with generalizations and errors, thin on content, and not a lot of substance. Like wads of cotton candy hawked at the state fair--colorful, enticing and sweet-tasting, but not much you can sink your teeth into.

Those glossy, cute articles are meant to touch lightly on a subject and toss a few factoids to the reader. They are designed to draw in visitors from the search engines to run up their per-click ad revenue meter. Unoriginal articles yielding a nugget or two of dubious information for the unsuspecting visitor. Empty calories.

You've seen them: "Winning strategies for bankruptcy," "How to beat a DUI," or "Don't let the government take your estate." The sensationalized title may grab your attention, but the accompanying story frames the subject matter in an overly-simplistic, superficial view. Pure fluff.

With legal information it's never simple. How do you know you're getting the real deal from some online article?

Look at the byline. Was the piece written by a knowledgeable practitioner in your state, or some person whose background is outside the field of expertise being presented? Does the writer cite (with links) authoritative, up-to-date primary legal sources to back up their position? Does the author state their professional credentials and their areas of proficiency, and are those credentials on point? Or is it merely listed as some staff writer? That "legal" or "personal financial" writer might be nothing more than a fledgling journalism student or random nobody trying to make a name for himself/herself. The Dunning-Kruger effect is pervasive, and the internet is filled with people who purport to know things they aren't qualified to speak on.

Stick with information from attorneys and law firms practicing in your jurisdiction, who know the applicable law and how it's applied. Seek out articles published by law professors. Government sources are often a good source of helpful legal pointers. Many legal topics of interest to consumers are effectively addressed by the state Attorney General's site. Keep in mind that these online sources are not dispensing legal advice; but rather, giving some basic tips to steer you in the right direction.

Contact your state or local bar association to find qualified attorneys to reach out to. Many of those attorneys will give a short initial consultation for free or at a reduced fee.

Do your research, read up with a critical eye. But before you draw any conclusions, talk to a qualified legal professional.